An experiment, not a verdict. Deciding what is truly positive or negative is extremely difficult, and in the long run maybe impossible. These scores are one rough attempt to explore whether it can be measured at all, and to start discussion. They are not a judgment of anyone and shouldn't be taken seriously as facts. Facts come from the cited sources; ratings and scores are opinions. Please read the full note.
Part of What People Do, an experiment in measuring the effects of the world's most influential people on all life. See all people →
Bill Gates (born 1955, Seattle) co-founded Microsoft with Paul Allen in 1975 and built it into the company that put a personal computer on almost every desk in the world. In 2000 he co-founded what became the Gates Foundation, one of the largest charities in history. In May 2025 he said he would give away “virtually all” of his wealth through it, and that the foundation will spend about $200 billion and then close at the end of 2045. [1] [2]
How we sort actions: each action is judged by its effect on all life (people, animals, plants, ecosystems and climate) by four measures: who it affects, how many, how long, and how sure the evidence is. Lasting, well-documented benefit goes under Positive. Lasting, well-documented harm goes under Negative. Mixed or uncertain effects go under Neutral. Each action gets a score from 0 (most harmful) to 100 (most beneficial), where 50 is neutral. For more info, see how we score.
Positive influences (17)
- Pledging nearly his whole fortune by 2045 (2025–present) 62
Pledged to give away virtually all his wealth. The foundation plans to spend about $200 billion, mostly on health and poverty, and then close at the end of 2045.
Effects: The foundation's budget rose to about $9 billion a year. That money arrives as government health aid fell by about 27% in 2025, and the foundation now projects the first rise in child deaths this century. Its spending cushions, but cannot replace, those cuts. The long-term results are still ahead. [2] [3]
Rated: strongly helpful · billions · a generation · 1 of 4 kinds of life · disputed or uncertain · role: led it - Funding a new tuberculosis vaccine (2024–present) 59
The foundation is paying about $400 million toward a 20,000-person trial of the M72 TB vaccine, which could be the first new TB vaccine in a century.
Effects: No results yet: the trial runs until about 2029. An earlier trial showed about 50% protection. TB kills over a million people a year, so success would matter enormously. [4]
Rated: strongly helpful · billions · a generation · 1 of 4 kinds of life · disputed or uncertain · role: major part - Funding clean-energy technology (Breakthrough Energy) (2015–present) 66
Founded Breakthrough Energy, which invests in low-carbon cement, steel, fertilizer, batteries and power.
Effects: Breakthrough Energy Ventures backs young companies in clean steel, cement, batteries and other hard-to-clean industries. Most are still early, so the emissions cut so far is small, but some could matter a great deal if they scale. [5]
Rated: strongly helpful · hundreds of millions · a generation · 4 of 4 kinds of life · disputed or uncertain · role: led it - Preparing for pandemics (CEPI, COVAX) (2015–present) 56
Warned in a 2015 TED talk that the world was not ready for a pandemic. In 2017 the foundation co-founded CEPI with $100 million to speed up vaccines against new diseases, and in 2020 it helped launch the global effort to get COVID vaccines to poorer countries.
Effects: COVAX, which CEPI helped create, shipped nearly 2 billion COVID vaccine doses to 146 countries and is estimated to have prevented 2.7 million deaths. It also fell well behind its targets while rich countries bought up early supply. [6] [7] [8]
Rated: strongly helpful · billions · about a decade · 1 of 4 kinds of life · mostly documented · role: one of several - Expanding access to contraception (2012–present) 58
Co-hosted the 2012 London Summit on Family Planning and pledged more than $1 billion toward reaching 120 million more women and girls with contraception.
Effects: By 2020 the FP2020 partnership counted 60 million additional women and girls using modern contraception, half its goal, with users in Africa up by 66%. Fewer unplanned pregnancies means fewer maternal deaths and, over time, less pressure on land and wildlife. [9] [10] [11]
Rated: strongly helpful · hundreds of millions · a generation · 2 of 4 kinds of life · mostly documented · role: one of several - Reinventing the toilet (2011–present) 60
Launched the Reinvent the Toilet Challenge to develop safe, sewer-free sanitation for the billions without it, which protects people and waterways.
Effects: The program produced more than 25 new sewer-free toilet and waste-processing technologies, but few are yet in wide use. Billions of people still lack safe sanitation. [12] [13]
Rated: strongly helpful · millions · a generation · 3 of 4 kinds of life · disputed or uncertain · role: led it - Co-founding the Giving Pledge (2010–present) 55
Co-founded the Giving Pledge with Melinda French Gates and Warren Buffett, asking billionaires to give away at least half their wealth. Few signers have followed through so far.
Effects: More than 250 billionaires have signed, but a 2025 analysis found only a handful have actually given away half their wealth. The total extra giving it caused is unclear. [14] [15]
Rated: mostly helpful · hundreds of millions · about a decade · 2 of 4 kinds of life · disputed or uncertain · role: major part - Founding TerraPower (next-generation nuclear) (2008–present) 55
Founded TerraPower, which received the first US construction permit for its Natrium reactor in Kemmerer, Wyoming, in March 2026. It could provide carbon-free power, but nuclear waste and cost are still open questions.
Effects: No power has been produced yet, and construction began in 2026. If it works, the design could help replace coal plants. If not, the money will have produced little. [16]
Rated: slightly helpful · millions · a century or more · 4 of 4 kinds of life · disputed or uncertain · role: led it - Funding polio eradication (2007–present) 59
The foundation is the largest donor to the Global Polio Eradication Initiative, with nearly $5 billion given.
Effects: Wild polio cases fell from hundreds of thousands a year to 99 in 2024, in just Afghanistan and Pakistan. But the oral vaccine can, in rare cases, mutate and spread, and in 2024 such vaccine-derived polio caused more cases (562) than the wild virus. A newer vaccine, nOPV2, is 80% less likely to do this, and over 2 billion doses have been given. [17] [18] [19] [20]
Rated: strongly helpful · billions · a century or more · 1 of 4 kinds of life · mostly documented · role: one of several - Founding the Institute for Health Metrics and Evaluation (2007–present) 57
Funded IHME with $105 million, then $279 million in 2017. Its Global Burden of Disease study tracks causes of death and illness worldwide and guides health spending.
Effects: Governments and agencies around the world use its Global Burden of Disease numbers to set health priorities. Critics say a single Gates-funded source now has outsized influence over which diseases get attention. [21]
Rated: mostly helpful · hundreds of millions · about a decade · 1 of 4 kinds of life · mostly documented · role: led it - Funding Guinea worm eradication (2005–present) 58
A major funder of the Carter Center's Guinea Worm Eradication Program. Only 10 human cases were reported in 2025, down from millions a year in the 1980s.
Effects: Cases fell from millions a year in the 1980s to 10 in 2025, sparing whole communities a painful, disabling disease. Infections in dogs are now the main barrier to finishing the job. [22] [23]
Rated: clearly helpful · millions · a century or more · 1 of 4 kinds of life · mostly documented · role: one of several - Slowing HIV in India (Avahan) (2003–2013) 60
Funded Avahan, an HIV prevention program in India. Studies estimate it prevented hundreds of thousands of infections, though the exact numbers are debated.
Effects: Studies estimate it prevented about 100,000 infections in its first five years, and possibly over 600,000 over ten years, though both estimates rely on modeling. [24]
Rated: clearly helpful · millions · about a decade · 1 of 4 kinds of life · mostly documented · role: led it - Fighting AIDS, TB and malaria (Global Fund) (2002–present) 57
The foundation is the largest private donor to the Global Fund, with nearly $5 billion since 2002, including a $912 million pledge in 2025.
Effects: The Global Fund says its partnership has saved 70 million lives since 2002. The foundation supplied a few percent of the Fund's money, so its share of that result is real but partial. [25] [26]
Rated: clearly helpful · billions · a generation · 1 of 4 kinds of life · well documented · role: small part - Developing the first malaria vaccine (2001–present) 58
Funded late-stage development of RTS,S, the first malaria vaccine, from 2001 to 2015. The WHO recommended it for children in Africa in 2021.
Effects: Malaria killed about 610,000 people in 2024, three-quarters of them young children in Africa. Since 2021, 24 countries have added malaria vaccines to routine immunization. They give partial protection, but even partial protection saves many lives at that scale. [27] [28] [29]
Rated: clearly helpful · hundreds of millions · a generation · 1 of 4 kinds of life · mostly documented · role: one of several - Launching Gavi, the Vaccine Alliance (1999–present) 70
Gave $750 million to launch Gavi, which says it has helped vaccinate more than 1.3 billion children in lower-income countries since 2000.
Effects: Gavi estimates its vaccines have prevented more than 20 million future deaths since 2000 and helped halve child mortality in the 78 countries it supports. [30] [31] [32]
Rated: clearly helpful · billions · a generation · 1 of 4 kinds of life · well documented · role: major part - Bringing the internet to public libraries (1997–2003) 56
The Gates Library Foundation helped put computers and the internet in US public libraries. Public access grew from about a quarter of libraries in 1996 to over 95% by 2002.
Effects: Public internet access spread to almost every US library, giving millions of people without home computers a way to look for jobs, do schoolwork and reach government services. [33] [34]
Rated: strongly helpful · millions · about a decade · 1 of 4 kinds of life · mostly documented · role: major part - Spreading personal computing (Microsoft) (1975–2008) 56
Led Microsoft as CEO until 2000 and full-time until 2008. MS-DOS and Windows made the PC a standard tool for billions of people, speeding up science and communication. The electronics boom it helped drive also created a record 62 million tonnes of e-waste in 2022, and only about 22% was properly recycled.
Effects: Billions of people gained a standard, affordable computer, which sped up science, education and business everywhere. The same boom drove mining, energy use and a fast-growing pile of electronic waste. [1] [35]
Rated: slightly helpful · billions · a century or more · 4 of 4 kinds of life · disputed or uncertain · role: major part
Neutral (effect not yet clear) (11)
- Climate memo shifts focus away from emissions targets (2025) 46
Argued that the climate fight should move from near-term emissions targets toward reducing human suffering. Some praised the focus on the poor. Many scientists warned it could weaken climate action.
Effects: The memo came just before the COP30 climate summit and drew both praise and sharp criticism from scientists. Coming from one of the biggest private funders of clean energy, it carries weight with governments and investors, though whether it changed any spending is not yet known. [36]
Rated: slightly harmful · hundreds of millions · a few years · 4 of 4 kinds of life · disputed or uncertain · role: led it - Pushing for the biggest US climate law (2022) 54
Personally lobbied Senator Joe Manchin, whose vote was decisive, during talks on the Inflation Reduction Act, and his Breakthrough Energy group increased its lobbying spending.
Effects: The law put hundreds of billions of dollars into clean energy, the largest climate investment in US history. Many groups pushed Manchin, so how much Gates's part mattered can't be known. [37] [38]
Rated: strongly helpful · hundreds of millions · about a decade · 4 of 4 kinds of life · disputed or uncertain · role: small part - Resisting a COVID vaccine patent waiver (2020–2021) 48
Opposed waiving COVID vaccine patents during the pandemic, arguing that factories and know-how, not patents, were the bottleneck. Critics said this slowed access in poorer countries. The foundation denies that it pushed Oxford into its exclusive AstraZeneca deal.
Effects: Poorer countries waited months longer for vaccines than rich ones. Experts still disagree on how much patents, compared with factories, supplies and rich-country hoarding, caused the delay. [39] [40]
Rated: mostly harmful · hundreds of millions · a few years · 1 of 4 kinds of life · disputed or uncertain · role: one of several - Backing meat alternatives (2013–present) 52
Invested in Impossible Foods and in lab-grown meat company Memphis Meats. These companies aim to replace livestock, a major source of emissions and land clearing.
Effects: Plant-based meat grew quickly, then US sales fell for several years in a row. It is still under 1% of the meat market, so its effect on emissions and land use so far is small. [41] [42] [43]
Rated: mostly helpful · millions · about a decade · 4 of 4 kinds of life · disputed or uncertain · role: small part - Becoming the largest private farmland owner in the US (2013–present) 50
Built up about 270,000 acres through Cascade Investment, which came to light in 2021. Gates says the goal is more productive farms. Critics worry about land concentration and what it means for soil and biodiversity.
Effects: The land is farmed by tenants, and there is little public evidence on whether its soil, water and wildlife are doing better or worse. The main documented effect is public concern about concentrated land ownership. [44]
Rated: mixed or unknown · millions · about a decade · 3 of 4 kinds of life · disputed or uncertain · role: led it - Funding solar geoengineering research (2007–present) 50
Helped fund research into dimming sunlight to cool the planet, including Harvard's program, whose planned outdoor test was cancelled in 2024. It could reduce warming or cause new harms. No one knows yet.
Effects: Research so far has been small and indoor. The planned outdoor test was cancelled after public opposition. Its main effect has been to move the idea into mainstream climate debate. [45]
Rated: mixed or unknown · billions · a century or more · 4 of 4 kinds of life · disputed or uncertain · role: one of several - Funding crop science for small farmers (2006–present) 54
One of the largest funders of CGIAR, the global network of agricultural research centers. In 2020 the foundation created Gates Ag One to breed hardier, climate-resilient crops.
Effects: Drought- and disease-resistant crop varieties from this research are in use across Africa and Asia. Critics say the focus on a few high-yield crops can reduce farm biodiversity. [46] [47]
Rated: mostly helpful · hundreds of millions · a generation · 2 of 4 kinds of life · disputed or uncertain · role: one of several - Pushing industrial farming in Africa (AGRA) (2006–present) 47
Main funder of the Alliance for a Green Revolution in Africa. A 2022 evaluation paid for by its donors found it missed its goals for small farmers' incomes and food security. Critics say it favored chemical fertilizer and fewer crop varieties.
Effects: Yields across AGRA countries rose about as fast as before it began. Critics link its push for chemical fertilizer to soil damage and the loss of traditional crop varieties, while supporters say farmers gained better seeds. [48] [49]
Rated: slightly harmful · hundreds of millions · about a decade · 3 of 4 kinds of life · disputed or uncertain · role: major part - Funding gene-drive mosquitoes (2005–present) 50
Main funder of Target Malaria, which is developing gene drives that could wipe out malaria-carrying mosquitoes. It could end a major disease, but releasing it would permanently change wild populations, with unknown effects on ecosystems.
Effects: No gene-drive mosquitoes have been released yet. Field trials are hoped for around 2030. The effect is still all potential: possibly ending much of malaria, possibly unexpected harm to ecosystems. [50]
Rated: mixed or unknown · billions · a century or more · 3 of 4 kinds of life · disputed or uncertain · role: major part - Shaping global health priorities and the WHO (2000–present) 50
The foundation became one of the World Health Organization's largest funders. Supporters say it brought money and focus. Critics say one private donor has too much say over global health priorities.
Effects: Diseases the foundation targets, like polio, got more money and attention. Critics argue other needs, like basic health systems, got less, and that the WHO depends too much on a single donor. [51] [52]
Rated: mixed or unknown · billions · about a decade · 1 of 4 kinds of life · disputed or uncertain · role: major part - Reshaping US public schools (2000–2016) 48
Spent billions on small schools, the Common Core standards and teacher evaluation. A RAND study found the $575 million teacher evaluation effort did not improve student results. Common Core spread to over 40 states with little public debate.
Effects: Tens of millions of students were taught under new standards and teacher-rating systems, but the main evaluation found the teacher program did not improve student results, and teachers and parents pushed back. [53] [54]
Rated: slightly harmful · millions · about a decade · 1 of 4 kinds of life · disputed or uncertain · role: led it
Negative influences (2)
- Holding major fossil fuel investments (2000–2014) 45
The foundation's endowment held at least $1.4 billion in oil, gas and coal companies in 2013. Holdings fell sharply the following year.
Effects: The investments made money from oil, gas and coal while the foundation funded health work hurt by climate change. After public pressure, most of the holdings were sold. [55] [56]
Rated: slightly harmful · hundreds of millions · about a decade · 4 of 4 kinds of life · disputed or uncertain · role: led it - Anti-competitive business practices (1990–2004) 39
US courts found in 2000–2001 that Microsoft illegally kept its PC operating-system monopoly. The EU fined it €497 million in 2004 for abusing its dominance. Competition and innovation in software were held back for years.
Effects: Netscape's browser, the main rival, collapsed, and Microsoft's dominance shaped the early web for years. The court settlement imposed rules that opened room for later rivals. [57] [58]
Rated: mostly harmful · billions · about a decade · 1 of 4 kinds of life · well documented · role: led it
Influence over time
How we score actions and draw this graph
References
- Britannica, "Bill Gates." britannica.com
- PBS NewsHour, "Bill Gates pledges remaining fortune to Gates Foundation, which will close in 2045," May 2025. pbs.org
- Fortune, "Bill Gates: childhood death rate under 5 sees first reversal this century," December 2025. fortune.com
- CIDRAP, "Phase 3 trial for TB vaccine candidate launches in South Africa," March 2024. cidrap.umn.edu
- Breakthrough Energy. breakthroughenergy.org
- TED, Bill Gates, "The next outbreak? We're not ready," 2015. ted.com
- CEPI, "CEPI officially launched," January 2017. cepi.net
- World Health Organization, "COVID-19 vaccinations shift to regular immunization as COVAX draws to a close," December 2023. who.int
- UK Government, "Family planning London summit, 11 July 2012." gov.uk
- Gates Foundation, "Landmark summit puts women at heart of global health agenda," July 2012. gatesfoundation.org
- FP2030, "The arc of progress, 2012–2020: what you need to know about the final FP2020 progress report." fp2030.org
- Gates Foundation, "Gates Foundation launches effort to reinvent the toilet," July 2011. gatesfoundation.org
- Gates Foundation, "Reinvent the Toilet Challenge and Expo." gatesfoundation.org
- The Giving Pledge, "About." givingpledge.org
- Fortune, report on Giving Pledge follow-through, August 2025. fortune.com
- US Department of Energy, "NRC Issues Construction Permit for TerraPower's Natrium Advanced Reactor," March 2026. energy.gov
- PBS NewsHour / AP, "Gates Foundation pledges $1.2B to eradicate polio," 2022. pbs.org
- Global Polio Eradication Initiative, fact sheet, September 2025. polioeradication.org
- PBS NewsHour, "More polio cases now being caused by vaccine than by the wild virus." pbs.org
- Global Polio Eradication Initiative, nOPV2 fact sheet, November 2025. polioeradication.org
- University of Washington, "Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation boosts vital work of the UW's Institute for Health Metrics and Evaluation," January 2017. washington.edu
- Gates Foundation, "Carter Center's Guinea Worm Eradication Program receives grant," April 2005. gatesfoundation.org
- The Carter Center, "10 Guinea worm cases reported last year, lowest on record," January 2026. cartercenter.org
- Imperial College London, "Avahan AIDS initiative may have prevented 600,000 HIV infections in India," 2013. imperial.ac.uk
- The Global Fund, "Global Fund private sector partners drive innovation, equity, access and impact in global health," November 2025. theglobalfund.org
- The Global Fund, "Global Fund reports 70 million lives saved but warns progress is at risk," September 2025. theglobalfund.org
- PATH, "Celebrating a milestone for the world's first malaria vaccine." path.org
- World Health Organization, "WHO recommends groundbreaking malaria vaccine for children at risk," October 2021. who.int
- World Health Organization, "New tools saved a million lives from malaria last year, but progress under threat as drug resistance rises," December 2025. who.int
- Gavi, "Gates Foundation" donor profile. gavi.org
- Gavi, the Vaccine Alliance, Progress Report. gavi.org
- Gavi, "Gavi's impact in 2024 in seven key statistics." gavi.org
- Pew Research Center, "New report on libraries and the digital divide," February 2004. pewresearch.org
- TechSoup, "The Gates Library Foundation: How digital inclusion came to libraries." blog.techsoup.org
- UNITAR and ITU, "Global E-waste Monitor 2024," March 2024. ewastemonitor.info
- TIME, coverage of Bill Gates' climate memo, October 2025. time.com
- Fortune, report on Bill Gates lobbying Sen. Joe Manchin on the Inflation Reduction Act, July 2022. fortune.com
- Bloomberg (via Accounting Today), "Bill Gates and the secret push to save Biden's climate bill," August 2022. accountingtoday.com
- KFF Health News, "Rather than give away its Covid vaccine, Oxford makes a deal with drugmaker," 2021. kffhealthnews.org
- Health Policy Watch, "Patents are not main roadblock to expanding vaccine production, says top Gates Foundation official," 2021. healthpolicy-watch.news
- Fortune, report on Bill Gates and Richard Branson investing in lab-grown meat company Memphis Meats, August 2017. fortune.com
- Quartz, "Bill Gates headlines an all-star list of investors pumping $75 million into meatless burgers," 2017. qz.com
- Good Food Institute, "Analyzing plant-based meat and seafood sales." gfi.org
- AgFunder News, "Bill & Melinda Gates revealed as largest private farmland owners in US," 2021. agfundernews.com
- MIT Technology Review, "Harvard halts its long-planned atmospheric geoengineering experiment," March 2024. technologyreview.com
- Gates Foundation, committed grant to CGIAR System Organization. gatesfoundation.org
- Devex, "Gates Foundation launches new agriculture-focused nonprofit," 2020. devex.com
- Mongabay, "Donors must rethink Africa's flagging green revolution, new evaluation shows," March 2022. news.mongabay.com
- SciDev.Net, "AGRA fails to deliver on promise to double yields." scidev.net
- MIT Technology Review, "Bill Gates doubles his bet on wiping out mosquitoes with gene editing," 2016. technologyreview.com
- KFF, summary of Politico, "Meet the world's most powerful doctor: Bill Gates," May 2017. kff.org
- Devex, "Big concerns over Gates Foundation's potential to become largest WHO donor," 2020. devex.com
- Governing (reprinting The Washington Post), "How Bill Gates pulled off the Common Core revolution," June 2014. governing.com
- RAND Corporation, "Improving Teaching Effectiveness: Final Report," June 2018. rand.org
- Chronicle of Philanthropy, "Gates fund held $1.4 billion in fossil-fuel stock in 2013." philanthropy.com
- Chronicle of Philanthropy, "Gates Foundation quietly sheds fossil-fuel stock." philanthropy.com
- US Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit, United States v. Microsoft Corp., opinion, June 2001 (hosted by the US Department of Justice). justice.gov
- Al Jazeera, "EU fines computer giant," March 2004. aljazeera.com
This page is updated as new information comes in. Suggestions with sources are welcome.